ALPAS MEDIA
RECRUITMENT AND EVP FILM FOR UK CONSULTANCIES

THE SAMENESS INDEX 2026 · AN ALPAS REPORT · JULY 2026

One script. Thirty-five logos.

How the 35 biggest UK consultancy firms sound to the graduates, senior hires and alumni they're trying to win. And why they all sound the same.

SEE WHERE YOUR FIRM SITS → DOWNLOAD THE REPORT (PDF)

(01) IN ONE LINE

We audited the public brand, purpose and careers language of the 35 largest consulting firms in the UK. They spend fortunes to stand out. In their own words, they've converged on a single shared script, and it's starting to cost them where it's hardest to fix: who says yes to a job offer.

None of this language can prove it was written by a human. Keep that thought.

(02) THE FINDING

Here is how often the same words do the work.

Share of the 35 largest UK consultancies whose own public copy, careers pages included, uses each term.

Global / scale
22/35 · 63%
Human / people-first
21/35 · 60%
Transformation
19/35 · 54%
Innovation
17/35 · 49%
AI, front and centre
15/35 · 43%
Impact
14/35 · 40%
Expertise / experts
14/35 · 40%
Trusted / trust
12/35 · 34%
Value
12/35 · 34%
Leading / #1 / the only
11/35 · 31%
Growth
11/35 · 31%
Partner / partnership
11/35 · 31%
Sustainable
10/35 · 29%
Purpose
8/35 · 23%
High-stakes / when it matters
8/35 · 23%

Sameness is what you get when everyone competes brilliantly on identical terms.

(03) THE SPECIFICS

3/4

open with an almost interchangeable "better world" purpose line. Swap the logos and no client could tell them apart.

"Impact that lasts"

Two firms, independently, built their strapline around the exact same phrase.

43%

now put AI front and centre, most arriving in the same eighteen-month window.

(04) IT'S NOT JUST THE WORDS

The other three levers have converged too.

PAY

Competing firms price talent within a couple of thousand pounds of each other. The Big Four say outright that salary isn't a differentiator.

AWARDS

The flagship "best consultancy" lists recognise 170 to 190 firms a year. Almost everyone has won, so almost no one has.

THE WORK ITSELF

Near-identical AI practices launched within eighteen months of each other. The work still differs underneath. It's just been communicated into sameness.

(05) THE AI CLIFF

AI has made generic infinite and free.

Any firm can now generate a flawless, on-brand, forgettable page in seconds. Sixty percent of these firms claim to be the human ones, in text. Almost none of them prove it. That gap is the whole opportunity.

3x

more trust in employees than in the company, on what it's really like to work there.

73%

of decision-makers trust demonstrated thinking over marketing.

(06) THE OPEN LANE

Real, not asserted.

The one lever candidates trust most is the one almost no one is using. Shown at the Four Moments that actually compound:

  1. IWinning the graduate
  2. IIWinning the senior hire
  3. IIIKeeping the rising star
  4. IVEarning the alumnus's referral

THE 10-SECOND TEST

Paste your firm's first line.

SAMENESS READING

5/15

This sentence could sit on almost any of the 35 sites we read.

  • GLOBAL · 22/35 FIRMS
  • PEOPLE-FIRST · 21/35 FIRMS
  • TRANSFORMATION · 19/35 FIRMS
  • INNOVATION · 17/35 FIRMS
  • TRUSTED · 12/35 FIRMS
GET THE FULL READING ON A CALL →

(07) YOUR FIRM

See where your firm sits.

RECOMMENDED · 30 MINUTES

Get your firm audited on a call

We put your firm through the same audit as the 35 and walk you through the exact words you share, which moment it's costing you, and a real number on it.

2 MINUTES · ON YOUR OWN

Take the Sameness Scorecard

Answer a few questions and get your Sameness Score, plus which of the Four Moments is costing you talent.

START THE SCORECARD →

Ben Etchells, Founder · ben@alpasmedia.com

(08) METHOD

Homepage lines, purpose statements and employer-brand pages of the 35 largest UK consultancies, audited July 2026 against a fixed vocabulary. A firm is counted for a term only where it appears in its own verified copy, so if anything this understates the overlap. Firm-level sourcing available on request.

SOURCES

  1. Pay: Poets&Quants (Jan 2026); Management Consulted Salaries Report 2026
  2. Awards: Consultancy.uk / FT UK's Leading Management Consultants 2024 to 2026
  3. Practices: Source Global Research; Deltek / Consultancy.uk; firm press releases
  4. Employee trust 3x: LinkedIn talent research
  5. 73% trust thought leadership: Edelman and LinkedIn B2B Thought Leadership Impact Report